« "Rocket Science" comes to baseball and the movies | Main | Handbook of the Economics of Art and Culture »

Follow Up to "Water Bottles,..."

April 19, 2005 09:39 AM

To follow up on my post on the overzealous promotion and consumption of water.

Your thirst over the course of a day, not within a brief span of hard work, is an excellent guide to your water requirements. Research in the Journal of Physiology shows that you don't need the 8 glasses of water "authorities" recommend (a lot of this advice comes from bottled water and sports drink manufacturers).

You need water when you are thirsty. Just realize that your thirst is a bit slow to come on line when you are doing hard work. You can anticipate this effect by sipping before you become thirsty if you are on a long hike or working in hot weather. Even then, there is little risk your body will fail to become thirsty in time to keep your water balance. How could it be otherwise when our ancestors survived the African Savanna for millions of years?

A bit of evolutionary reasoning tells us: 1. that thirst is an adaptive mechanism evolved over thousands of generations of humans; it can't be all that wrong. 2. the urgency of thirst is compelling, another evolved adaptation that keeps us from ignoring this important signal. 3. humans are the only carnivore that can operate at high daytime temperatures; wild cats can't because they lack the thermoregulatory system and sweating systems of humans. This adaptation gave humans a niche in which to operate where there was less competition from other, lethal (to us) carnivores. 4. watering places were dangerous; prey (including other humans) attracted carnivores, so it would have been maladaptive for humans to have required water on a continuous basis, as some trainers practice and recommend for their clients. To do so would have entailed continuous exposure to carnivores. 5. hunter gatherers obain a good deal of their water from their consumption of plant food as well as the blood of prey. Similarly, we modern humans get a lot of it in our food. I hope this makes clear the need to think beyond proximate or mechanism-based explanations (you get thirsty to manage your water balance) to evolutionary explanations that give a deeper understanding of why the proximate mechanism evolved and how it works in a broader scheme.

Unlike your hunger mechanisms, which go awry at the low energy flux sedentary individuals live at, your thirst mechanism is pretty much spot on. There are some individuals whose sense of thirst is over-developed even to the point of craving water well beyond physiological requirements. This "water intoxication" may stem from constant water binging.

You need water when you feel thirsty and not otherwise. Excess water bloats you and is hard on the kidneys. Water does help to cleanse the kidneys, but too much puts a burden on them. When you carry extra water you carry extra weight (which slows you down and increases your work rate), you dilute the minerals in your blood which changes the chemical gradient across cell membranes (intefering with metabolism and thermal control), and your blood volume can rise to a level that stresses your heart. Exess blood volume builds up in the circulatory system and leaks through the vessels into the interstices of the body (the same thing that happens with congestive heart failure).

I could go on, but a more general point is lurking here. A lot of fitness advice is just repeated rather than thought through and it is probably true that most manufacturers go beyond the pale in marketing their products.

· Evolutionary Fitness

Comments

Posted by: mathew [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 1, 2006 4:20 AM

Posted by: Flower Online [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 12, 2006 7:27 AM

tworzenie stron internetowych tworzenie stron internetowych ; soczewki kontaktowe soczewki kontaktowe ; zdrowa żywność zdrowa żywność ; reklama w internecie reklama w internecie ; sm ; ma ; mpa ; apteki warszawa apteki warszawa ; agroturystyka agroturystyka mazury ; jiddu krishnamurti jiddu krishnamurti ; nauka angielskiego nauka angielskiego angielski ; stomatologia warszawa stomatolog warszawa ; opony opony ; klimatyzacja klimatyzacja ; domy opieki warszawa domy opieki warszawa ; apteka apteka ; projektowanie stron internetowych projektowanie stron internetowych ; ogłoszenia nieruchomości, wynajem mieszkań warszawa ogłoszenia nieruchomości ; nieruchomości warszawa, wynajmę kawalerkę warszawa nieruchomości warszawa ; nieruchomości, wynajmę mieszkanie warszawa nieruchomości ; korepetycje angielski angielski korepetycje ; sigmund freud ; jk

Posted by: outsider [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 10, 2006 12:41 PM

Art, it's great to have you back, breathing some intellectual life - as opposed to tunnel vision science and fads - into the area of fitness!

Although hunger mechanisms may 'go awry at the low energy flux levels sedentary individuals live at', I think you would agree that the hunter-gatherer lifestyle was more high energy flux - and thus their hunger mechanisms would be working well.

If you take your third para with its five conclusions of evolutionary reasoning and develop the same model for food intake and physical activity as well as water intake, this will provide a better guide to diet and activity than rules based on scientific physiology or gym hearsay. It will also make the point (which is clearly so obvious to you that you don't repeat it, but is ignored - wilfully or out of ignorance - by many others) that diet and physical activity are two aspects of the one phenomenon: a healthy human life. Your three-day food diary, for example, makes most sense extrapolated to a week or two and read in parallel with an activity/movement diary. To round out the picture, we need to consider sleep, intellectual activity, social interaction and the nature of the surrounding environment.

It is so easy to ignore how far we have removed our paleolithic minds and bodies from the environments to which they were matched, almost to perfection.

Posted by: Keith Thomas at May 3, 2005 5:56 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?